Andrea’s 25

6300 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725, USA

About Andrea’s 25

4.5 / 5 from reviews

Over 20 years ago, our Father & Cousin, Andrew Sorrentino, opened a pizzeria in Lake George, NY. This humble start marks the beginning of a journey that led our family to where we are today.

Moving forward, Andrew opened a variety of restaurants. Spending his time behind the line as head Chef, he pioneered the legacy we continue to carry. Andrew’s first venture into family-style Italian cuisine was Matteos. After building then selling the business, Andrew looked to his sons Salvatore & Matthew along with their cousin Peter to found something new.

Andrew passed away in October of 2009.

In his honor, Salvatore, Matthew, and Peter came together and founded Andrea’s 25 of Commack.

The secret to their success cannot be seen or felt, but can be smelled right from their kitchen doors. Because after all, its all about the Food.

Our Address
6300 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725, USA

Brett Harte
June 12, 2021

I can't say enough good things about our dining experience at Andrea's 25. Everything was delicious and fresh... we'll be dining here more, that's for certain. Thanks to everyone Andrea's 25...

Keith A.
February 02, 2021

Upon walking in, we waited at least 10 minutes to be acknowledged. We had plenty of time to notice the clutter near the front window and hostess area. Entering the dining area, the lighting was a bit bright where we were seated, and the noise level was akin to sitting in a school cafeteria. It also took a while between waiter visits. For the price paid, there are more ambient locations. The food, however, was very good.

Sheldon Marts
March 08, 2021

First-rate ambience and super attentive service. The meals were fresh and delightful. Will absolutely recommend this place to others. Fair rates and large meals. Great work.

Pam's Daily Dish
February 09, 2021

My husband and I had dinner on Saturday night at Andrea 25. We ate in their new igloo and it was really cozy and warm. The service was excellent and the food was delicious as always. We’re definitely going back in a few weeks to eat in the igloo again.

Nichole Labarbara
March 20, 2021

I have been there twice now and it is very good. Everything is nice and fresh, and the portion size is good.

Win A $25 Gift Card

Join The Restaurant Club