Old school burger joint serving fresh, local daily prepared burgers, hot dogs,
in-house cut fries, tater tots and other comfort foods
Two working class guys that have been in the restaurant most of our lives. We have worked every aspect of the
restaurant operation from washing dishes to executive managers. We both had a vision to one day work together on our own project. This is where
Boxcar Burgers was born.
Went to boxcar right before the pandemic hit and the food was so good. The owner was so nice as well. Recently just ordered on uber eats from here again. The food still delicious.. definitely better than five guys
We happened upon this burger joint after flying into McArthur, and popped in with no prior info. Lucky us! Each of us ordered something different, and we were all three pleased. My single cheeseburger with everything was great. Loved the chopped pickles & onions! I ordered tater tots and they were perfectly crispy. My friend had the double cheeseburger and fries. Same reaction from him...very good. And my kiddo had a fully dressed hot dog. Although she loved the kraut and toppings, she didn't love the hot dog casing. I tried it and liked it, but liked the burger better! There was a dipping sauce that we didn't know what to do with, but once we tried it, we put it on everything. The restaurant area was spotless and the staff was friendly enough. Glad we went.
Ordered two double cheeseburgers and a milkshake. The burgers were really good. Two thin patties and not greasy. I added bacon and they were crispy. Bun was soft.. Just a perfect thing to have when you're on your way home and hungry. The PB milkshake was so thick and wasn't overly sweet. So good. Legit. The young woman who served us was friendly and happy. That kindness rubs off. Thanks so much. Will pop by again.
This place hit the spot! Perfectly cooked thin paddy burgers. I ordered a double cheeseburger with bacon and a side crispy tator tots. The tots were literally the best I’ve ever had which is kind of annoying because now everyone else are going to seem soggy and gross. The portions were perfect and I felt satisfied but not too much where I felt like I was going to need someone to roll me to my car. We also got some milk shakes for the road. Those were excellent too. Overall, this is a burger and shake place was worth the visit and we will return if we are in the area again. Also, the staff was super friendly and helpful.
Better than Five Guys or Shakeshack, for a fraction of the cost. These guys do not mess around. As someone who loves his burgers, their ingredients are top notch because I am always beyond satisfied. A real gem of long island
Join The Restaurant Club